Start with the finding that annoys people, including us.
Backing the highest officially-rated horse in every race returns -15.30%, and it wins 19%. Backing the favourite returns -9.03%. So the horse the official handicapper rates best is a worse bet than the horse the market makes favourite.
In handicaps specifically it is -15.92%, worse again.
Our own model tells the same story from the other direction. It reads far more than the official rating: recent form, course record, distance record, the lot. Across 5,631 races its top pick wins 22.5% of the time, and it has returned −17.0% on 5,320 bets, which is −£9,033.
That is a lot of form study arriving at a loss.

